Two bundles, two very different jobs
The Double Dutch and the Holy Sheet Duo are both bundles from Great Jones, but they solve different kitchen problems. The Double Dutch gives you two enameled cast-iron Dutch ovens that handle stovetop braising, roasting, and slow cooking. The Holy Sheet Duo is a pair of half-sized sheet pans with a nonstick nontoxic coating, designed for baking and roasting. Your choice comes down to whether you need heavy-duty cookware for one-pot meals or lightweight bakeware for cookies and vegetables.
What each bundle actually includes
- Double Dutch: Get the best of both worlds — and $165 in savings — with our two-piece set of Dutch ovens. The Dutchess, our 6.75-quart enameled cast-iron Dutch oven, is perfect for family-style cooking (it fits a whole roast chicken); our round, 3.5-quart Dutch Baby is ideal when you’re making a side dish, or just cooking for yourself and a pal. This tells you the Double Dutch is a two-size set: a large 6.75-quart pot for big meals and a smaller 3.5-quart pot for sides or small batches. The savings compared to buying separately are significant.
Double Dutch - Holy Sheet Duo: Our award-winning half-sized sheet pan, Holy Sheet, is a kitchen superhero: bold and colorful in appearance, but the custom nonstick, nontoxic coating allows for a quick, easy, and drama-free cleanup. Two sets you up for success and gets you the best deal: one for savory (crispy broccoli, chicken thighs) and one for sweet (cookies!). The Holy Sheet Duo is two identical sheet pans, letting you dedicate one to savory roasting and one to sweet baking. The nonstick coating simplifies cleanup and avoids the need for parchment in most recipes.
Holy Sheet Duo
Key differences at a glance
- Material and cooking method: Double Dutch uses enameled cast iron, which retains heat for stovetop braising, searing, and oven roasting. Holy Sheet Duo uses a steel pan with a nonstick coating, best for baking and roasting at moderate oven temperatures.
- Capacity and versatility: Double Dutch offers two different sizes (6.75 qt and 3.5 qt), so you can cook a whole chicken in one and a side in the other. Holy Sheet Duo gives you two same-size pans, useful for batch baking or separating savory and sweet.
- Storage: The Double Dutch's Dutch Baby nests inside The Dutchess, saving cabinet space. The Holy Sheet Duo stacks flat; two pans take up about the same footprint as one.
- Stovetop compatibility: Double Dutch is safe for all stovetops including induction. Holy Sheet Duo is oven-safe but not designed for stovetop use.
The trade-off you need to weigh
If you regularly make soups, stews, braised meats, or one-pot pasta dishes, the Double Dutch gives you two Dutch ovens that can handle high heat and even heat distribution. The nesting design means you don't sacrifice much storage space for the second pot. The Holy Sheet Duo, on the other hand, is the better choice if you bake frequently — cookies, sheet cakes, roasted vegetables — and want a nonstick surface that makes cleanup fast. The coating is made without PFOA, PFAS, PTFE, Lead, or Cadmium, which matters if you prefer nontoxic cookware.
You can't use the Holy Sheet Duo for stovetop cooking, and the Double Dutch's enameled cast iron is heavier and requires more careful handling to avoid chipping. Neither set is wrong, but one will match your daily cooking habits better.
Color and customization options
- Double Dutch: Choose between six matte colors to match your style. Double Dutch lets you pick different colors for the two pots (e.g., Broccoli Dutchess with Mustard Dutch Baby), so you can coordinate or contrast.
- Holy Sheet Duo: Available variant evidence shows color combinations like Raspberry / Mustard, Broccoli / Pepper, and Mustard / Broccoli. Holy Sheet Duo also offers two-color combos, letting you pair a bold shade with a neutral one or match both pans exactly.
Which one should you buy?
Buy the Double Dutch if you want a two-pot system for stovetop-to-oven cooking, need different sizes for different meals, and value the heat retention of cast iron. Buy the Holy Sheet Duo if you bake or roast often, prefer a lightweight nonstick pan, and want to keep savory and sweet separate without extra cleanup. Both bundles offer real savings over buying the pieces individually, but they serve different primary purposes.
